Study on determination of
seven transition metal ions in water and food by microcolumn high-performance liquid
chromatography
Liu Hongcheng, Er Zhu, Li
Qiwan, Hu Qiufen #, Yin
Jiayuan #
(Supervision & Testing Center For Farm Products Quality, Ministry Of Agriculture,
Kunming, 650223; # Department Of Chemistry, Yunnan University, Kunming
650091, China )
Abstract A new method for the
simultaneous determination of seven transition metal ions in water and food by microcolumn
high-performance liquid chromatography was developed. The lead, cadmium, mercury, nickel,
cobalt, silver and tin ions were pre-column derivatized with
tetra-(4-aminophenyl)-porphyrin (T4-APP) to form color chelates, then the Hg-T4-APP,
Cd-T4-APP, Pb-T4-APP, Ni-T4-APP, Co-T4-APP,
Ag-T4-APP and Sn-T4-APP chelates was enriched by solid phase
extraction with C18 cartridge, and eluted the retained
chelates from the cartridge with tetrahydrofuran
(THF). The chelates were separated by microcolumn high-performance
liquid chromatography and detected with a photodiode array detector
from 350- 600 nm. The detection limits of lead,
cadmium, mercury, nickel, cobalt, silver and tin are 4 ng/L, 3 ng/L, 6 ng/L, 5
ng/L, 5 ng/L, 6 ng/L, 4 ng/L respectively in the original samples. This method had been
applied to the determination of the seven transition metal ions in water and food sample
with good results.
Keywords microcolumn high-performance liquid chromatography,
tetra-(4-aminophenyl)-porphyrin, transition metal ions
1. INTRODUCTION
The RP-HPLC technique with pre-column
derivatization has been proved to be a favorable and reliable technique for the separation
and determination of trace amount of metal ions. Many kinds of reagents have been examined
as pre-column derivatization regents, and several review articles have appeared on this
approach [1- 8]. Among the various kinds of reagents, porphyrin ligands are
useful because of its high molar absorptivity and high stability. The molar absorptivity
of metal-porphyrin chelates above 105 is often found. Porphyrins can form very
stable 1:1 chelates with many metal ions and these chelates are very difficult to
decomposing during the HPLC separation [1-3]. Due to these facts, porphyrin
reagents have received more and more attentions and are widely applied to the simultaneous
determination of metal ions [9-12].
Determination of trace lead, cadmium, mercury, nickel, cobalt, silver
and tin in water and food is very important because of their biological significance [13].
In this paper, a ZORBAX Stable Bound microcolumn (2.0¡Á50 mm, 1.8 m m) with pH range
1.5-12 was used for the separation of Hg-T4-APP, Cd-T4-APP, Pb-T4-APP,
Ni-T4-APP, Co-T4-APP, Ag-T4-APP and Sn-T4-APP
chelates with pH 10 mobile phase. The seven chelates were separated completely within 2
min. Based on this; a rapid, sensitive and selective method for the simultaneous
determination of seven transition metal ions in water and food was developed.
2. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
2.1 Apparatus
The HPLC system consisted of a Waters 2690 Alliance separation model
and a 996 photodiode array detector (Waters Corporation, USA). The pH values were
determined with a Beckman F-200
pH meter. The absorbance measurement was measured with a Shimidzu UV-2401
spectrophotometer. The atomic absorption spectrometry analysis was made
with a Shimidzu AA-6701F atomic absorption spectrophotometer.
The separation column used was a ZORBAX Stable Bound microcolumn (2.0´
50 mm, 1.8 m m) (Agilent Corporation, USA). The cartridge used is Zorbax C18 solid
phase extraction cartridge (1 cc/50mg£¬30
m m) (Agilent Corporation, USA). The extraction was performed on Waters Solid Phase
Extraction (SPE) Device (which can prepare twenty samples simultaneously).
2.2 Chemicals
All of the solutions were prepared with ultra-pure water, which was obtained from a
Milli-Q50 SP Reagent Water System (Millipore Corporation, USA). Pb(II), Cd(II), Hg(II),
Ni(II), Co(II), Ag(I) and Sn(IV) standard solution: 1.0 mg/ml (Obtained from Chinese
Standards Center), a working solution of 0.2 mg/ml was prepared by diluting this standard solution. HPLC
grade methanol and THF (Fisher Corporation, USA). Pyrrolidine-acetic acid buffer solution:
0.5 mol/L, pH=10. TritonX-100 solution, 2.0% (v/v). T4-APP was synthesized by
our laboratory as described in the literature [14], and was dissolving with THF to make a
1.5´ 10-4 mol/L of solution. The glass and Teflon wares used were soaked
in 5% of nitric acid for a long time, and then thoroughly wash with pure water.
2.3 Standard procedure
An appropriate volume of standard or the sample was transferred into a 50 ml of volumetric
flask. To which, 5.0 ml of T4-APP THF solution, 2 ml of Triton X-100 solution
and 5 ml of 0.5 mol/L pH=10 pyrrolidine-acetic acid buffer solution were added. The
solution was diluted to a volume of 50 ml with water and mixed well. The mixture was
heated in boiling water bath for 15 min. After cooled, the solution was passed through the
C18 cartridge at a flow rate of 10 ml/min. After the enrichment had finished,
the retained chelates were eluted from the cartridge with 1.0 ml of THF at a flow rate of
5 ml/min in an opposite direction. The solution was filtered with filters of 0.45 m m and
adjusted to the volume of 1.0 ml. 2.0 ml of sample was injected for HPLC analysis. A
tridimensional was recorded from 350~ 600 nm with photodiode array detector and the
chromatogram of 435 nm is shown in Fig.1.
Fig.1 Chromatogram of standard sample and real sample: 1) Real sample, 2)
Standard sample
The Injection volume is 2.0 ml. Detection wavelength is 435 nm. Other conditions as in standard
procedure.
3. RESULT AND DISCUSSION
3.1. The selection of porphyrin Reagent
In this paper, seven porphyrin reagent, tetra-(4-bromophenyl)-porphyrin (T4-BPP),
tetra-(4-chlorophenyl)- porphyrin (T4-CPP), tetra-(4-methoxyphenyl)-porphyrin
(T4-MOPP), tetra-(4-methylphenyl)-porphyrin (T4-MPP),
tetra-(4-sulfophenyl)-porphyrin (T4-SPP), tetra-(4-hydroxyphenyl)-porpyrin (T4-HPP)
and tetra-(4-aminophenyl)-porpyrin (T4-APP) were studied as pre-column
derivatization regents for Co(II), Ni(II), Sn(IV), Hg(II), Pb(II),
Ag(I) and Cd(II) ions. The experiment show that all of the seven reagents
can form colored chelates with Co(II), Ni(II), Sn(IV), Hg(II), Pb(II), Ag(I) and
Cd(II). The T4-MPP, T4-CPP, T4-MOPP, T4-BPP
and their metal-chelates have a very poor solubility in water. To get a stable solution,
it is required adding large proportion of organic solvents to improve the solubility,
which is inconvenient. The T4-SPP and T4-HPP can form soluble
chelates with metal ions. But in alkaline medium, the chelates have a poor retention on
reversed-phase column because the sulfonic group or the hydroxy group on porphyrin
reagents can ionize. So T4-SPP and T4-HPP are unsuitable to use as
pre-column derivatization reagents in this experiment. T4-APP can form soluble
chelates in aqueous medium when Triton X-100 is existed, and the chelates have good
retention on reverse-phase column. So T4-APP was selected as pre-column
derivatization regents in this experiment.
3.1 Precolumn derivation
According to the literature [14-16], the optimal pH is 8.2 ~
11.8 for the reaction of Co(II), Ni(II), Sn(IV), Hg(II), Pb(II), Ag(I) and Cd(II) with T4-APP, so a 0.5 mol/L of pH=10 pyrrolidine-acetic acid
buffer solution was recommended to control pH. It was found that 1.0 ml of 1.5¡Á10-4
mol/L T4-APP THF solution was sufficient to complex 3.0 mg of Ni(II), Sn(IV),
Co(II), Hg(II), Pb(II), Ag(I) and Cd(II). But in real samples, the foreign ions, such as
Mg2+, Pd2+, Fe3+, Mn2+, Zn2+, Bi3+,
Ba2+, Cu2+ and the like, can complex with T4-APP to
consume reagents. So more T4-APP was needed. In this experiment, A 5.0 ml of
1.5´ 10-4 moL/L T4-APP solution was recommended in this
experiment.
The reaction of Co(II), Ni(II), Sn(IV), Hg(II), Pb(II), Ag(I) and
Cd(II) with T4-APP was slow at room temperature. Heating can accelerate the
reaction. The reaction was complete for heating in boiling water bath for 10 min and the
chelate can keep stable for 5 h after cooling, so heating 15 min was selected.
3.2 Solid phase Extraction
Both of the enrichment and the elution were carried out on a Waters SPE device (which can
prepare twenty samples simultaneously). The flow rate was set to 10 ml/min when enrichment
and 5 ml/min when elution.
Some experiments were carried out in order to investigate the retention
of metal-T4-APP chelates on the cartridge. It was found that the Sn-T4-APP,
Ni-T4-APP, Co-T4-APP, Hg-T4-APP, Pb-T4-APP,
Ag-T4-APP and Cd-T4-APP chelates could be retained on the cartridge
quantitatively when they pass the cartridge as aqueous solution. The capacity of the
cartridge for metal-T4-APP chelates was 32 mg in a 50 ml of solution. In this
experiment, the cartridge has adequate capacity to enrich the metal-T4-APP
chelates.
In order to choose a proper eluant for the retained T4-APP
and its metal-chelates, various organic solvents were studied. It was found that the THF,
isopentyl alcohol, acetonitrile, acetone, ethanol and methanol could elute the metal-T4-APP
chelates from cartridge quantitatively. The effect of the various eluants for the retained
metal-T4-APP chelates was in the following squence: THF > isopentyl alcohol
> acetonitrile > acetone > ethanol > methanol. So THF was selected. The
metal-T4-APP chelates have a good stability in a weak alkaline medium. A
pyrrolidine-acetic acid buffer salt of 0.05 mol/L (pH=10) in THF could increase the
stability of the metal-T4-APP chelate during the elution. So THF (containing
0.05 mol/L pyrrolidine-acetic acid buffer salt (pH=10)) was selected as eluant. Experiment
showed that it was easier to elute the retained T4-APP and its metal-chelate on
cartridge in reverse direction than in forward direction, so it was necessary to upturned
the cartridge when elution. 1.0 ml of the THF eluant was sufficient for eluted the metal-T4-APP
chelate from cartridge quantitatively at a flow rate of 5 ml/min.
3.3 Spectrophotometric properties
From tridimensional chromatogram recorded by photodiode array detector, the absorption
spectrum of metal-T4-APP chelates was obtained. The maximum absorption
wavelengths of Ni-T4-APP, Sn-T4-APP, Co-T4-APP, Hg-T4-APP,
Pb-T4-APP, Ag-T4-APP and Cd-T4-APP are 428 nm, 432 nm,
432 nm, 451 nm, 466 nm, 428 nm and 438 nm. To get maximum sensitivity, each metal-T4-APP
chelates were monitored at its maximum absorption wavelength.
3.4 Chromatographic Separation
The Co-T4-APP, Sn-T4-APP, Ni-T4-APP, Hg-T4-APP,
Pb-T4-APP, Ag-T4-APP and Cd-T4-APP chelates were stable
in weak alkaline medium. The pH of mobile phase within 8.5-11.8 can avoid the chelates
decomposing and get a good peak shape. So methanol-tetrahydrofuran (95:5, v/v, containing
0.05 mol/L pyrrolidine-acetic acid buffer salt, pH=10.0) was selected as mobile phase.
Because the routine silica bonds reserved phase chromatographic column was not stable in
pH 10, a ZORBAX Stable Bound microcolumn (2.0´ 50 mm, 1.8 m m) was selected as
analytical column in this experiment. ZORBAX Stable Bound column have a good stability in
pH 1.5-12.
3.5 Calibration graphs
Under optimum conditions, regression equations of metal-T4-APP chelates were
established based on the standard samples injected and its peak areas. Limits of detection
are calculated by the ratio of signal to noise (S/N=3). The results were shown in Table-1.
The reproducibility of this method was also examined for 10 mg/L of Ni(II), Sn(IV),
Co(II), Pb(II), Cd(II), Ag(I) and Hg(II). The relative standard deviations (n=10) were
shown in Table 1 too.
Table 1
Regression Equation, Coefficient and Detect limit
Components |
Regression Equation |
Linear Range( mg/L) a |
Coefficient |
Detect limit (ng/L) b |
RSD%(n=10) |
Cd-T4-APP |
A=2.56¡Á106
C+172 |
0.
5- 520 |
r=0.9995 |
3 |
1.6 |
Pb-T4-APP |
A=2.12¡Á106
C-125 |
0.6-
620 |
r=0.9996 |
4 |
2.2 |
Hg-T4-APP |
A=1.78¡Á106
C+88.5 |
0.9-
980 |
r=0.9998 |
4 |
1.8 |
Ag-T4-APP |
A=1.26¡Á106
C-76.4 |
0.9-
980 |
r=0.99958 |
6 |
2.1 |
Co-T4-APP |
A=2.16¡Á106
C-138 |
0.6-
830 |
r=0.9997 |
5 |
1.8 |
Sn-T4-APP |
A=1.87¡Á106
C+79.2 |
0.5-
620 |
r=0.9996 |
4 |
2.2 |
Ni-T4-APP |
A=2.04¡Á106
C-128 |
0.6-620 |
r=0.9998 |
5 |
1.7 |
a In the measured solution; b in the original
digested sample |
3.6 Interference
Under the pre-column derivatization
condition, the foreign ions of Mg2+, Cu2+, Pd2+, Rh3+,
Fe3+, Mn2+, Zn2+, Pt2+, Ba2+, Bi3+
and Ru3+, which can reacts with T4-APP to form color chelates. To
examine the selectivity of this method, the interference of foreign ions was investigated.
When 5.0 ml of 1.5¡Á10-4 mol/L T4-APP was used, with 10 mg/L of Ni(II),
Sn(IV), Pb(II), Co(II), Cd(II) and Hg(II) respectively, the tolerance amount with an error
of ¡À 5% was 5000 mg/ml for Fe(III), Mg(II), 1000 mg/ml for Cu(II), Bi(III), Zn(II), Ba(II) and 500 mg/ml for Pd(II),
Pt(II), Ru(III), Rh(III). The results show most foreign ions do not interfer with the
determination.
3.7 Application to Food samples
0.2-0.30 g of sample was weighed accurately and put into the Teflon high-pressure
microwave acid-digestion bomb (Fei Yue Analytical Instrument Factory, Shanghai, China).
2.5 ml of concentrated nitric acid and 2.5 ml of 30% hydrogen peroxide were added. The
bombs were sealed tightly and then positioned in the carousel of the microwave oven (Model
WL 5001, 1000 W, Fei Yue Analytical Instrument Factory, Shanghai, China). The system was
operated at full power for 6.0 min. The digest was evaporated to near dryness. The residue
was dissolved with 5 ml of 5% of nitric acid and transferred into a 50 ml of calibrated
flask quantitatively, and diluted to volume with water. The Co, Ni, Sn, Hg, Pb, Ag and Cd
contents were analyzed by using a proper volume of this solution according to general
procedure. The results (deducted the reagents blank) were shown in Table 2.
Table2
Determination results of certified standard food samples
Samples |
Standard value ( mg/g) |
By this method( mg/g) |
Standard Deviation (%) |
RSD%(n=5) |
Flour (GBW08426) |
As(0.285), Ag(-), Ba(21.2), Bi(0.342), Ca(2900), Cd(0.218),
Ce(1.25), Co(4.71), Cr(3.76), Cu(10.2), Fe(54), Hg(0.086), Mg(360), Mn(6.3), Mo(0.735),
Ni(1.83), Pb(0.852) , Sn(2.18) |
Ag(-), Cd(0.202) , Co(4.86) , Hg(0.078) , Ni(1.68) , Pb(0.824) ,
Sn(2.36) |
Ag(-), Cd(-7.33) , Co(3.18) , Hg(-9.30) , Ni(-8.20) , Pb(-3.29) ,
Sn(8.26) |
2.2 |
Tea Leaf
(GBW08505) |
As(0.191), Ag(-), Ba(15.7), Ca(2840), Cd(0.128), Co(2.25), Cr(0.8),
Cu(16.2), Fe(373), Hg(0.142), Mg(2240), Mn(766), Ni(5.61), Pb(1.06), Sn(1.24), Se(0.0412),
Zn(38.7), |
Ag(-),, Cd(0.136) , Co(2.11) , Hg(0.136), Ni(5.84), Pb(1.18), Sn(1.
38), |
Ag(-),, Cd(6.25) , Co(-6.22) , Hg(-4.23), Ni(4.10), Pb(11.31),
Sn(11.29), |
1.8 |
3.8 Application to
water samples
For the fresh water (tap water, river water
and lake water) the water sample was analyzed according to the general procedure. The
results (deducted the reagents blank) were shown in Table 3, together with the results of
a recovery test by added 0.2mg of Ni, Co, Sn, Ag, Pb, Cd and Hg in water sample and
diluted to 50 ml of final solution. For plant effluents, the sample was digested as
literature [13] and analyzed according to the general procedure. The results
(deducted the reagents blank) were shown in Table-3 too, together with results of a
recovery test by added 0.2 mg of Ni, Co, Sn, Ag, Pb, Cd and Hg in water sample and
diluted to 50 ml of final solution. A standard method using atomic absorption spectrometry
(AAS) had also been used as reference method. The results (AAS) were shown in braces.
Table 3
Determination results (mg/L) of the water sample with this method
Components |
Samples ( mg/L) |
RSD£¥(n=5) |
Recovery£¥(n=5)b |
River water |
Lake water |
Plant effluent |
Tap water |
Co |
18.5(17.4)a |
14.6(15.2)a |
56.8(55.6)a |
12.8(14.6)a |
1.8 |
98.9 |
Ni |
26.2(28.2)a |
15.8(16.5)a |
44.2(48.5)a |
16.2(15.2)a |
2.3 |
99.2 |
Sn |
16.7(17.8)a |
31.5(30.7)a |
28.5(30.1)a |
8.67(8.32)a |
3.1 |
101.3 |
Cd |
5.46(5.96)a |
11.2(11.8)a |
16.7(15.2)a |
2.22(2.13)a |
2.2 |
100.7 |
Ag |
8.61(8.62)a |
18.7(16.2)a |
18.6(17.8)a |
- |
1.8 |
96.5 |
Pb |
12.5(11.8)a |
8.65(8.76)a |
22.8(24.4)a |
6.58(6.76)a |
2.1 |
98.1 |
Hg |
2.87(2.81)a |
5.62(5.41)a |
12.5(13.5)a |
- |
1.7 |
102.3 |
a The values of water sample with AAS method; bThe
average recovery of five kinds of water samples |
4. CONCLUSION
In this paper, tetra-(4-aminophenyl)-porphyrin was used as pre-column derivatization
reagent for lead, cadmium, mercury, nickel, cobalt, silver and tin ions, and the ZORBAX
Stable Bound microcolumn with pH range 1.5-12 was used for the separation of Hg-T4-APP,
Cd-T4-APP, Pb-T4-APP, Ni-T4-APP, Co-T4-APP,
Ag-T4-APP and Sn-T4-APP chelates with pH 10 mobile phase. The seven
chelates were separated completedly within 2 min. The metal-chelates were preconcentrated
by C18 cartridge and the enrichment factor of 50 was achieved. The detection
limits of this method reach the ng/L level. Most foreign ions do not interfer with the
determination. This is one of the sensitive, selective and rapid methods for the
simultaneous determination of Ni, Co, Sn, Pb, Cd, Ag and Hg.
REFERENCE
[1] Shi Z H, Fu C G. Chinese Journal of Analysis and Testing Technology and
Instruments (Fenxi Ceshi Jishu Yu Yiqi), 1996, 2 (3): 28.
[2] Shi Z H, Fu C G. Talanta, 1997, 44: 593.
[3] Biesaga M, Pyrzynska K, TrojanowiczM. Talanta, 2000, 51: 509.
[4] Cheng J K. Chemical Journal of Chinese University (Gaodeng Xuexiao Huaxue Xuebao),
1995, 16: 696.
[5] Wang P, Lee H K. J.Chromatogr. A., 1997, 789: 437.
[6] Wang Y F, Zhou T Z. Chinese Journal of Analytical Laboratory (Fenxi Shiyansi), 1999,
18 (5): 91.
[7] Stahlberg J. J.Chromatogr. A., 1999, 855: 3.
[8] Malik A K, Seidel B S, Faubel W et al. Chemical & Environmental Research., 2000,
9: 3.
[9] Yin J W, Wang G L, Xiao Z F. Chinese Journal of Chromatography (Sepu)., 2000, 18: 436.
[10] Chen X H, Zhu Y, Yang J J. Chinese Journal of Analytical Chemistry (Fenxi Huaxue).,
28 (2000) 1260
[11] Igarashi S, Takagai Y. Anal.Chem.Acta., 2000, 424: 263.
[12] Shi Z H, Wang Y H, Fu C G. Chinese Journal of Chromatography (Sepu), 2000, 18: 27.
[13] Edited by Chinese Environment Protection Agency. Analysis method of water and waste
water, 3th Ed.; Environmetal Science Press: Beijing,1989; 578-579.
[14] Lei Y W, Ge CC, Zeng D Z. Chinese Journal of Chemical Reagent (Huaxue Shiji),
1994, 16 (2):105.
[15] Fang M, Hu S K. Chinese Journal of Rock and Mineral Analysis (Yekuang Ceshi), 1991,
10: 318.
[16] ZengYune, Zhang Huashan, Chen Zhenhua. Handbook of Modern Chemical Reagents, the
Forth Fascicule. Chromogenic Agent of Inorganic Ion, Chemical Industry Press: Beijing,
1989, 785.
¡¡
¡¡
|