http://www.chemistrymag.org/cji/2004/06c098pe.htm

Dec. 10, 2004  Vol.6 No.12 P.98 Copyright cij17logo.gif (917 bytes)


Measurement of liquid-liquid equilibria for quaternary mixtures of water, ethanol, diisopropyl ether and toluene

Pan Zhongjuan, Chen Yao
(Department of Chemistry, Jinan University, Guangzhou, 510632, China)

Abstract Experimental tie-line data for quaternary mixtures of water + ethanol + diisopropyl ether + toluene system have been measured at temperature 298.15 K and ambient pressure. The experimental quaternary LLE data have been successfully correlated by using a modified UNIQUAC model. Absolute arithmetic mean deviation of tie-lines between the experimental and calculated results for the quaternary LLE system measured in this work is 2.35 in mole percent.
Keywords Liquid-liquid equilibria, Fuel additives, Quaternary mixtures, Modified UNIQUAC model.

Supported by the Foundation of Ministry of Education(2002-247), Foundation of Scientific Research from Guangdong Province(2003C33101) and Foundation of Jinan University (640071).

1. INTRDUCTION
There is a considerable current interest in the use of fuel additives to improve gasoline performance as anti-knocking agents and to reduce air pollution. Methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE) is used mostly because of its low Reid vapor pressure (RVP) and the availability of the feedstock ethanol from renewable resources. However, MTBE has the drawbacks of easily dissolving in water and of difficult removal from water. In addition, it is resistant to microbial decomposition. These facts have promoted research on the possible use of ethers of higher molecular weights, harmless for the environment. Diisopropyl ether (DIPE) is effective in reducing automotive CO emissions and has been considered a good alternative to MTBE as an oxygenated additive. To assess the effect of the additives in gasoline reformulation, we need a fundamental knowledge about multi-component phase equilibria of the mixtures containing these ether compounds. Although many liquid-liquid equilibrium (LLE) investigations of ternary mixtures formed by MTBE or DIPE have been made[1-5], only a few LLE data of quaternary mixtures with MTBE or DIPE were reported.
    In this work, one quaternary LLE data for the water + toluene + ethanol mixtures with DIPE measured at the temperature 298.15 K and ambient pressure is reported. An accurate description of the experimental LLE data of the quaternary system by using a modified form of the UNIQUAC model[6] which include additional ternary and quaternary parameters coming from three-body and four-body interactions is presented. For the reliable representation of the quaternary LLE system, the constituent ternary systems of water + toluene + ethanol[7], ethanol + DIPE + water[5] and toluene + DIPE + water[4], are necessary to obtain the ternary parameters. The vapor-liquid equilibrium (VLE) data and mutual solubilities of the constituent binary mixtures have been available from the literatures[5, 8-11].

2. EXPERIMENTAL
Toluene and ethanol were supplied by Guangzhou Chemical Reagent Factory, with minimum purities of 99.5 and 99.7 mass%, respectively. Diisopropyl ether was obtained from Tianjin Chemical Reagent Institute with 99.0 mass%. Water was twice distilled.

M.S.£ºMagnetic stirrer       S1 S2£ºSyringe
W
£ºSYP Water bath           U£ºUpper phase
R
£ºSWQ Control heater       L£ºLower phase
D
£ºGlass cell                       Mix.£ºMixer

Fig. 1
Schematic diagram for liquid-liquid equilibria measurement

    Quaternary LLE measurements were carried out at (298.15¡À0.01)K. The experimental apparatus are schematically shown in Figure 1. The mixtures were stirred by using a magnetic stirrer for 3 hours, and settled for 2 hours. It is sufficient to separate into two phases. The samples withdrawn from upper and lower phases were analyzed by a gas chromatography. The accuracy of the measurements was estimated within ¡À0.001 in mole fraction. Table 1 shows experimental LLE results for the water + DIPE + ethanol + toluene mixtures.

Table 1 Equilibrium phase compositions in mole fraction () for the quaternary of water(1) + ethanol(2) + toluene(3) + diisopropyl ether(4) mixtures at 298.15 K

Organic phase

Aqueous phase

{water + ethanol + toluene + diisopropyl ether }a

=0.25

0.1266

0.0182

0.2173

0.6379

0.9765

0.0224

0.0000

0.0011

0.0479

0.0437

0.2365

0.6719

0.9854

0.0143

0.0000

0.0003

0.0281

0.1149

0.2207

0.6363

0.8780

0.1204

0.0000

0.0016

0.1115

0.1887

0.1808

0.5190

0.8330

0.1644

0.0000

0.0026

=0.5

0.1010

0.0180

0.4576

0.4234

0.9414

0.0568

0.0000

0.0018

0.1162

0.0929

0.4012

0.3897

0.8325

0.1650

0.0000

0.0025

0.0359

0.1649

0.4160

0.3832

0.8130

0.1853

0.0000

0.0017

0.0834

0.2340

0.3509

0.3317

0.7216

0.2701

0.0033

0.0050

0.1674

0.2849

0.2770

0.2707

0.7132

0.2805

0.0019

0.0044

0.2092

0.3648

0.2258

0.2002

0.6812

0.3083

0.0023

0.0082

0.1707

0.4494

0.2146

0.1653

0.7576

0.2270

0.0057

0.0097

= 0.75

0.0790

0.0264

0.6729

0.2217

0.9259

0.0733

0.0000

0.0008

0.0265

0.0733

0.6823

0.2179

0.8579

0.1414

0.0000

0.0007

0.0625

0.1061

0.6306

0.2008

0.7945

0.2047

0.0000

0.0010

0.0798

0.2033

0.5439

0.1730

0.7155

0.2803

0.0019

0.0023

0.0896

0.2426

0.5159

0.1519

0.6715

0.3205

0.0042

0.0038

0.1154

0.2648

0.4800

0.1398

0.7002

0.2912

0.0046

0.0040

0.0925

0.2959

0.4853

0.1263

0.6449

0.3423 0.0070 0.0058

0.1192

0.3238

0.4402

0.1168

0.6187

0.3622

0.0117

0.0073

0.1489

0.3412

0.4026

0.1073

0.6042

0.3712

0.0158

0.0088

0.1816

0.3553

0.3649

0.0982

0.6511

0.3249

0.0154

0.0086

a: Obtained by mixing pure water and ethanol with {toluene+ (1-)diisopropyl ether }.

3. MODIFIED UNIQUAC MODEL
To represent the experimental quaternary LLE data as well as the binary VLE and ternary LLE data, we use the modified UNIQUAC model with binary and additional ternary and quaternary parameters[6]. The excess molar Gibbs free energy for quaternary systems is expressed by two contributions of the combinatorial and residual termand.
(1)
    The combinatorial term is given by a modified form of Gmehling et al[12].
(2)
    where the coordination number Z is set to 10, the segment fraction
f, the corrected segment fraction f
', and the surface fraction q, are given by
, , (3)
and the residual term is modified by introducing the third parameter C to the residual term of the extended UNIQUAC model[13] and by including additional ternary and quaternary parameters and .
(4)
    The adjustable binary parameter, obtained from the constituent binary phase equilibrium data, is defined by the binary energy parameter aji.
(5)
    The activity coefficient of component 1 in the quaternary mixture, derived by partial differentiation of the Gibbs free energy with respect to the number of moles of component 1, is expressed by


(6)
    The expressions of , and are obtained successively by cyclic advancement of the subscripts in Eqn.(6), by changing 1 to 2, 2 to 3, 3 to 4, and 4 to 1. For ternary mixtures, the adjustable ternary parameters,
t231,
t132 and t123, are needed to represent the ternary LLE data. The quaternary parameters, t2341 , t1342 ,t1243 and t1234, are necessary for the description of the quaternary LLE data.

4. CALCULATION PROCEDURE
The binary energy parameters for the miscible mixtures were obtained from the VLE data reduction using the following thermodynamic equations:
(7)
(8)
    where P, x, y, and
¦Ã are the total pressure, the liquid phase mole fraction, the vapor phase mole fraction, and the activity coefficient, respectively. The pure component vapor pressure, , was calculated by using the Antoine equation with coefficients taken from the literatures[14]. The liquid molar volume, , was obtained by a modified Rackett equation[15]. The fugacity coefficient, ¦µ, was calculated by the Eqn.(8). The pure and cross second virial coefficients, B, were estimated by the method of Hayden and O'Connell[16]. The binary energy parameters for the partially miscible mixtures were obtained by solving the following thermodynamic equations simultaneously.
(9)
and ( I, II = two liquid phases ) (10)
    The ternary and quaternary LLE calculations were carried out using the Eqns.(9) and (10). For the ternary systems of type 1 having a plait point, two-parameter UNIQUAC models predict generally larger solubility envelope than the experimental one. Good correlation of the ternary LLE systems usually needs not only the binary parameters but the ternary parameters. The ternary parameters,
t231, t312 and t123 were obtained by fitting the model to the ternary experimental LLE data and the quaternary, t2341 , t1342 ,t1243 and t1234, were determined from the quaternary experimental LLE data using a simplex method[17] by minimizing the objective function:
= (11)
where min means minimum values, i = 1 to 3 for ternary mixtures or i =1 to 4 for quaternary mixtures, j = phases I and II, k = 1,2,
¡­,n (no. of tie-lines), M = 2ni, and x = (the liquid phase mole fraction).

5. CALCULATED RESULTS
Table 2 shows the molecular structural parameters of pure components. The values of r and q for DIPE were taken from the literature[5], and the others taken from Prausnitz et al.[18]. The value of q' was fixed to obtain a good representation for all binary VLE systems. The third parameter C of Eqns. (4) and (5), sets empirically as 0.65 in such a way to reproduce the binary VLE and ternary LLE results as well as possible[6], was used in this work. Table 3 presents the constituent binary energy parameters of the modified UNIQUAC model along with the root-mean-square deviations between the experimental and calculated values for pressure, for temperature, for liquid phase mole fraction, and for vapor phase mole fraction.
    Table 4 shows the ternary parameters obtained in fitting the modified UNIQUAC model to the experimental ternary LLE systems, and root-mean-square deviation of the mole fraction of tie-lines between the experimental and calculated results for the ternary LLE systems. Figure 2 compares the experimental and calculated LLE of the ternary mixtures making up the quaternary mixtures of water + ethanol + DIPE + toluene system at 298.15 K. Table 5 summarizes the calculated results for the quaternary mixtures obtained in fitting the modified UNIQUAC model with binary, ternary and quaternary parameters to the quaternary LLE data. The model accurately correlates the quaternary experimental LLE data measured in this work.

Table 2 Structural parameters for pure components

Component

r

q

q¡¯

Ref.

Ethanol

2.11

1.97

1.404

[18]

DIPE

4.74

4.09

q 0.75

[5]

Toluene

3.92

2.97

q 0.75

[18]

Water

0.92

1.40

1.283

[18]

q' was fixed in this work.

Table 3 Calculated results of binary phase equilibrium data reduction

System
(1+2)

Temp.
/K

No.of data points

a12/K

a21/K


/Torr


/K


x103


x103

Ref.

Ethanol+Water

298.15

10

212.70

-46.98

0.6

0.0

1.5

6.0

[8]

Ethanol+DIPE

298.15

9

-24.30

701.41

6.4

0.0

1.6

2.9

[9]

Ethanol+Toluene

308.15

10

48.97

862.96

0.4

0.0

0.2

2.2

[10]

DIPE+Water

298.15

MSa

1590.60

166.68

[5]

Toluene+Water

298.15

MSa

1713.30

752.99

[11]

a: Mutual solubilities.

Table 4 Calculated results for ternary liquid-liquid equilibrium at 298.15 K

System
(1+2+3)

No. of tie-line

Ternary parameters

dxa,c
[mol%]

dxb,c
[mol%]

Ref.

Water +
Ethanol +
Toluene

17

t231 = -0.35457
t132 = 0.66670
t123 = -0.27213

1.80

0.50

[7]

Water +
Ethanol +
DIPE

9

t231=-0.42243
t132=1.48480
t123=-1.74600

1.78

1.42

[5]

Water +
Toluene +
DIPE

10

t231=0.22581
t132=0.35329
t123=-3.05090

0.51

0.19

[4]

a: Predicted with binary parameters alone. b: Correlated with binary and ternary parameters. c: Root-mean-square deviations.

Table 5 Calculated results for quaternary liquid-liquid equilibrium at 298.15 K

System
(1+2+3+4)

No. of tie-line

Quaternary parameters

dxa,c         dxb,c
[mol%]     [mol%]

Water +Ethanol
+ DIPE +Toluene

21

t2341=-2.2755     t1342=0.0101
t1243=0.0576     t1234=3.3344

3.10

2.35

a: Predicted with binary parameters alone. b: Correlated with binary , ternary and quaternary parameters. c: Absolute arithmetic mean deviation.

6. CONCLUSION
The quaternary LLE of the water + ethanol + DIPE + toluene system were measured at the temperature 298.15 K in this work. The experimental quaternary LLE data were satisfactorily correlated by using the modified UNIQUAC model including binary, ternary and quaternary parameters. The quaternary LLE results correlated by the modified UNIQUAC model give slightly better agreement with the experimental results than those predicted by the model.


Fig. 2 Experimental and calculated LLE of two ternary mixtures making up (water + ethanol + DIPE + toluene) at 298.15K. ¡ñ-------¡ñ, experimental tie-line; -----, Predicted by the modified UNIQUAC model with binary parameters alone; , Correlated by the modified UNIQUAC model with binary and ternary as well as quaternary parameters.

REFERENCES
[1] Alkandary J A, Aljimaz A S, Fandary M S et al. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 2001, 187-188: 131-138.
[2] Peschke N, Sandler S I. J. Chem. Eng. Data, 1995, 40: 315-320.
[3] Higashiuchi H, Watanabe T, Arai Y. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 1997, 136:141-146.
[4] Pan Z J, Chen Y, Dong Y H, et al. J Jinan University, impressed.
[5] Arac A, Marchiaro A, Rodriguez A, et al. J Chem Eng Data, 2002, 47: 529-320.
[6] Tamura K, Chen Y, Yamada T, et al. J Solution Chem, 2000, 29 (5): 463-488
[7] Washburn R E, Beguin A E, Beckord O C. J Am Chem Soc, 1939, 61: 1694-1695.
[8] Hall D J, Mash C J, Penberton R C. NPL Report Chem, 1979, 95:1-32.
[9] Lee M J, Hu C H. Fluid Phase Equibria, 1995, 109: 83-98.
[10] Kretschmer C B, Wiebe R. J Am. Chem Soc, 1949, 71: 1793-1797.
[11] Ruiz F, Prats D, Gomis V. J Chem Eng Data, 1985, 30: 412-416.
[12] Gmehling J, Li J, Schiller M. J Ind Eng Chem Res, 1993, 32: 178-193.
[13] Nagata I. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 1990, 54: 191-206.
[14] Riddick J A, Bunger W B, Sakano T K. Organic Solvents.4th edn., New York :Wiley Interscience,1986.
[15] Spencer C F, Danner R P. J Chem Eng Data, 1972, 17: 236-241.
[16] Hayden J G, O
¡¯Connell J P. J Ind Eng Chem Process Res Dev, 1975, 14: 209-216.
[17] Nelder J A, Mead R. J Computer, 1965, 7: 308-313.
[18] Prausnitz J M, Anderson T F, Grens E A, et al. Computer Calculation for Multicomponent Vapor-Liquid and Liquid-Liquid Equilibria . Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1980

[ Back ] [ Home ] [ Up ]