Leaching experiment of trace elements in
lignite residue from underground gasification
Liu Shuqin,
Zhao Limei, Yu Xuedong, Yu Li
(UCG Research Centre of Chemistry & Environmental Engineering College,Beijing Campus
of China University of Mining & Technology, Beijing 100083)
Received on Aug. 9, 2004;
Supportted by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.20207014)
Abstract The leaching behavior of trace
elements in lignite residue from underground gasification was studied through column
leaching experiment. Elements studied are Cr, Co, Ni, Cu, Mo, Cd, Sr,
As. The comparison on leaching rate and leaching intensity was conducted at different pH
value of solution and the influence of trace elements existence form was studied. In
addition, the impact of trace elements leaching on surrounding underground water was
evaluated. The results show, Sr and Mo give priority to strong leaching, Cr, Co, Cu, Cd,
As behave as middle leaching, and Ni shows hardy leaching. Leaching intensities of the
trace elements are remarkably influenced by the pH value of leaching solution and elements
existence form. The levels of the 8 trace elements in leachates are higher than that of
the standard for underground water, thus, long-term leaching of lignite residue from
underground gasification would potentially contaminate underground water around the
underground gasification area, which should be paid more attention.
Keywords Underground Coal Gasification; leaching experiment; trace element
1 INTRODUCTION
UCG (underground coal gasification) is a process in which underground coal, without
mining and transportation, is directly converted into combustible gas. It offers a
potentially means of clean coal conversion into high-energy fuels[1]. However,
the process generates massive amounts of solid waste in the form of gasification residue,
which is left underground different from surface gasification. The composition of the
gasification residue has been a subject of environmental interest because it may contain
toxic components such as trace hazardous elements which, if leached, may contaminate
underground water since UCG is usually conducted in the environment of fresh water[2].
An extensive research has been carried aimed at various types of
combustion ash and combustion-ash leachate originating with coal-fired power plants.
However, only limited information has been obtained about UCG residue. With the future
trend toward greater utilization of UCG as an energy source, there will be a need for such
information.
The objective of this investigation was to study the leachable levels and
leaching behavior of 8 trace elements from UCG residue. The elements studied were Cr, Co,
Ni, Cu, Mo, Cd, Sr, As. It is expected to provide basic data for pollution protection of
underground water around the underground gasification zone.
2 EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Sampling
Simulation test of UCG of lignite was conducted in the UCG central laboratory of China
University of Mining & Technology. The test lignite was provided by Dayan Coal Mining
Group. Block coal, rock, sand, and clay were used to simulate in-site underground coal
deposit condition. The test lasted for 150h through blowing oxygen and steam
simultaneously with production of middle caloric gas. After the UCG simulation test,
samples were taken along the gasification tunnel through opening and investigation of the
gasifier. UCG residue of 5kg was collected and reduced to 1kg by quartering. The obtained
sample was crushed less than 100 order and prepared for use.
2.2 Leaching procedure
HNO3 was used to adjust the pH value of deionized water into 2.0, 4.0, and 6.5
respectively and served as leaching solution. Glass column with length of 70mm and
diameter of 25mm was processed for leaching experiments and dipped in HNO3
before use.
Representative 15g portions of residue sample were filled into the
leaching column and leached with deionized water maintained at different pH 2.0, 4.0, 6.5
for 80h. Flow rate controlled was 4.0ml/h to keep the liquid surface 10cm higher than
solid surface and liquid/solid ratio 3:1. Leachates were collected with 50ml bluck with
interval of 5h or 10h, diluted to 50ml, filtered, and analyzed by Platform ICP-MS
(inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer). As was determined by atomic absorption
spectrometry. The true value of trace element concentration was obtained by subtract the
blank value of the leaching solution.
3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Leaching rate and leaching intensity
The concentration levels of the 8 trace elements in the leachates at different pH value
were obtained. In order to compare the leaching trend and leaching levels of the trace
elements from UCG residue, leaching intensity was introduced and calculated through the
following model[3]:
In which, Lx, the leaching intensity of
certain trace element; ax, concentration of trace element in the leachate,
mg/L; V, total volume of the leachate, ml£»Ax,
content of trace element in the sample of UCG residue, mg/g£»M, weight of the total sample, g£»t, leaching time. The calculated leaching intensity and leaching
rate are shown in table 3.1.
Table 3.1 Leaching index of trace elements in UCG residue of lignite at different pH
pH |
Element |
Total amount£¨ug£© |
Leachable amount£¨ug£© |
Leaching rate£¨%£© |
Leaching intensity |
¡¡
¡¡
¡¡
2.0 |
Cr |
640.0 |
78.2 |
12.22 |
1.53 |
Co |
190.8 |
92.2 |
48.52 |
6.06 |
Ni |
540.5 |
82.8 |
15.33 |
1.92 |
Cu |
384.2 |
129.4 |
33.69 |
4.21 |
Mo |
309.1 |
174.3 |
56.37 |
7.05 |
Cd |
7.5 |
1.77 |
23.60 |
2.95 |
Sr |
2801.4 |
1555.3 |
55.52 |
6.94 |
As |
186.0 |
27.4 |
14.74 |
1.84 |
4.0 |
Cr |
640.0 |
65.4 |
10.22 |
1.27 |
Co |
190.8 |
55.2 |
28.93 |
3.62 |
Ni |
540.5 |
40.5 |
7.50 |
0.94 |
Cu |
384.2 |
86.2 |
22.45 |
2.81 |
Mo |
309.1 |
96.7 |
31.30 |
3.91 |
Cd |
7.5 |
1.11 |
14.80 |
1.85 |
Sr |
2801.4 |
1158.2 |
41.34 |
5.16 |
As |
186.0 |
22.5 |
12.12 |
1.51 |
6.5 |
Cr |
640.0 |
41.2 |
6.44 |
0.80 |
Co |
190.8 |
18.2 |
9.54 |
1.19 |
Ni |
540.5 |
19.2 |
3.56 |
0.44 |
Cu |
384.2 |
47 |
12.24 |
1.53 |
Mo |
309.1 |
29.55 |
9.56 |
1.19 |
Cd |
7.5 |
0.48 |
6.40 |
0.80 |
Sr |
2801.4 |
485.5 |
17.33 |
2.17 |
As |
186.0 |
13.6 |
7.31 |
0.91 |
It shows that Sr represents highest leachable amount. Mo
and Sr have higher leaching rate and leaching intensity and their leaching rate are more
than 50%. Co takes the second place. Cr, Ni, As provides lower leaching rate and leaching
intensity. Cd has the lowest leachable amount while its leaching rate attains 23.6%. In
addition, the leaching rate and leaching intensity of the trace elements rises when pH of
the leaching solution decreases, among which, Co, Ni, Mo, Sr are remarkably influenced and
Cr, As are less affected.
In term of the
following division principle: Lx¡Ý5, strong leaching£¬1¡ÜLx¡Ü5, middle leaching£¬0.5¡ÜLx¡Ü1, weak leaching, and
Lx<0.5, hardy leaching, trace elements studied are classified into different rank and
shown in table 3.2. The results show, Sr and Mo give priority to strong leaching, which is
similar to those in coal combustion ash[4]. Cr, Co, Cu, Cd, As mainly behave as
middle leaching, and Ni is classified as hardy leaching. All the trace elements attain
middle leaching when the pH of leaching solution decrease to 2. Trace element, which has
higher leaching intensity, is remarkably influenced by pH.
Table 3.2 Leaching rank of the trace elements at different pH
pH value |
pH=2.0 |
pH=4.0 |
pH=6.5 |
Strong
leaching (Lx¡Ý5) |
Co, Mo, Sr |
Sr |
|
Middle
leaching (1¡ÜLx¡Ü5) |
Cr, Ni, Cu, Cd, As |
Cr, Co, Cu, Mo, Cd, As |
Co, Cu, Mo, Sr |
Weak
leaching (0.5¡ÜLx¡Ü1) |
|
Ni |
Cr, Cd, As |
Hardy
leaching (Lx<0.5) |
|
|
Ni |
3.2 Influence of trace element existence form
on leaching behavior
Leaching behavior of the trace elements depends heavily on their existence form[5].
It is usually considered that trace elements leaching becomes difficult following the
order: exchangeable, bound to carbonate and Fe & Mn oxides, bound to organic matter,
and residual, since in this order trace elements are more tightly combined[6].
Trace elements in exchangeable form are easily to be leached because they are combined to
the particulate surface only through adsorption-desorption process. Leaching of trace
elements bounding to carbonate is remarkably influenced by the pH value of leaching
solution, which affects the solubility of carbonates. In the case of trace elements
bounding to organic matter, only under oxidizing conditions in natural waters, organic
matter can be degraded, leading to a release of soluble trace metals. The residual should
contain mainly primary and secondary minerals, which may hold trace metals within their
crystal structure. These metals are not expected to be released in solution over a
reasonable time span under the conditions normally encountered in nature.
The partitioning of the element existence form in UCG residue of
lignite through sequential chemical extraction is shown in table 3.3. It is observed, the
exchangeable form of Mo takes up more than 20%, thus Mo shows strong leaching. Sr
represents higher leaching rate and leaching intensity since 45.62% of Sr exists in
carbonates and Fe-Mn oxides. The fraction of Cd bounding to carbonates and Fe-Mn oxides
accounts for more than 30%, which leads to higher leaching rate. But its leachable amount
is lower. Proportion of Ni found in residue is higher than 70%, thus it is weak leached.
Mo and Sr take on higher leachable amount and represent a large fraction in carbonates,
thus their leachable amount are remarkably affected by pH of the leaching solution.
Table 3.3 Partitioning of the trace element existence form
Element |
Unit |
Exchangeable (%) |
Bound to carbonates
and Fe-Mn oxides (%) |
Bound to organic matter (%) |
Residual (%) |
Cr |
% |
8.08 |
8.42 |
9.09 |
74.41 |
Co |
% |
14.54 |
15.87 |
5.64 |
63.95 |
Ni |
% |
11.76 |
9.31 |
7.65 |
71.28 |
Cu |
% |
2.12 |
19.36 |
14.45 |
64.07 |
Mo |
% |
22.49 |
26.50 |
9.83 |
41.18 |
Cd |
% |
7.65 |
33.37 |
9.69 |
49.29 |
Sr |
% |
7.41 |
55.62 |
7.13 |
29.84 |
As |
% |
7.45 |
7.89 |
8.99 |
75.67 |
During the process of UCG, majority of the carbonates and organic matter in coal
are decomposed in the high temperature and trace elements are transferred into metal
oxides. But when gas flows through the long gasification tunnel, the alkaline metal oxides
may react with CO2, produced through coal burning, to form carbonates. In the
same time, UCG process involves underground block coal which makes gasification
incomplete. The UCG residue may be mixed with small amount of original coal and there
exist certain amount of carbonates. Therefore, the percentage of carbonates form in the
residue is still high and it remarkably affects the leaching behavior of trace elements.
In addition, trace elements in exchangeable form still exist in UCG residue since ashes
produced through UCG are mainly left in the long gasification tunnel and UCG gas carries a
small quantity out.
Leaching behavior of
the trace elements also lies on the property of the element, which influences the
solubility of the metal oxides. In addition, leaching behavior of trace elements is also
related to other functions. For example, the absorption of ferric oxides will reduce the
solubility of trace elements.
3.3 Analysis of trace element leaching on
environment
Fig.1 shows the concentration profiles of the trace elements with leaching time at pH 4
with exception for Sr and Mo. It is observed that concentrations of Cr, Cd in leachates
decrease with time. Leaching curve of As, Cu, Co, Ni behaves as parabola. The leaching
peak of As lies in 30-40h and the leaching peak of Ni and Co present in 30-40h and 25-30h
respectively. In addition, the leaching peak of Cu occurs in 40-50h and continues to be
leached till 80h, which means leaching balance has not been reached in 80h.
The maximum
leachable concentrations of the trace elements in the leachates are Sr, 9.8ug/ml, Mo,
0.8321ug/ml, As, 0.084ug/ml, Cd, 0.0047ug/ml, Cr, 0.2120ug/ml, Cu, 0.5104ug/ml, Co,
0.2554ug/ml, and Ni, 0.2292ug/ml respectively and all exceed the concentration standard of
underground water (GB/T14848-9), which indicates that long-term leaching of trace elements
in UCG residue has the possibility of contaminating surrounding underground water. In the
case of in-situ UCG, dissolve of acid
gases such as CO2, H2S may increase the acidity of surrounding water
and thus affect the leaching trend of trace elements from UCG residue. Therefore, UCG area should be separated and avoided from
contacting with surrounding water system.
The potential of
UCG residue influence on underground water needs further investigation through dynamic
leaching experiment and detailed investigation of geological and hydraulic condition of
the gasification area.
Fig.1 Leaching profiles of trace elements at pH 4
4 CONCLUSION
Sr and Mo give priority to strong leaching, Cr, Co, Cu, Cd. As mainly behave as middle
leaching, and Ni shows hardy leaching. Leaching intensities of the trace elements are
remarkably influenced by the pH value of leaching solution. Leaching behavior of trace
elements depends primarily on their existence form. Presence of certain amount of
carbonates and exchangeable form in UCG residue increased the leaching tendency of trace
elements. Comparison of trace element levels in leachates and concentration standard of
underground water shows that long-term leaching of UCG residue has the possibility of
contaminating surrounding underground water, which should be attached more importance. The
basic leaching characteristics of the above trace elements would provide basic dates for
pollution prevention of underground water environment near UCG site.
REFERENCES
[1] Yu L. Kuang Ye Yi Cong (Chinese), 1990,
4: 1-10.
[2] Elloitt M A. Chemistry of Coal
Utilization. 1991, Beijing: Chemical Industry Publishing House. 317-319.
[3] Wang Y Q, Ren D Y et al. Environmental Science (Chinese), 1996,17 (1): 16-19.
[4] Matsukata M et al. Proceedings of Int.Conf. on Coal Science. Canada: Sep.
1993:321-324.
[5] Zhao F H, Ren D Y. Coal Geology & Exploration (Chinese), 1998, 26 (4):14-17.
[6] Wang Q C, Shao Q C et al. Environmental Chemistry (Chinese), 1996,15 (1): 20-26.
¡¡
|